I can’t tell you how many people come to me unsure about wearing colorful eyeliner. They don’t know if they can pull it off, they aren’t sure what shade to wear, they don’t know what eyeshadow to wear with it—the list goes on. When colorful eyeliner is too bright or bold, it can be difficult to pull off and can distract from the rest of your look. Subtle color eyeliner is actually really easy to make work, especially when you’re working with shades that compliment your eye color.

I’m really excited to add three new shades to the Jones Road Best Pencil collection: Violet, Ivy, and Onyx. They’re the same formula you know and love (precise, blendable, crisp), now in subtle hues that will make your eyes pop. Here’s what you need to know:

The Best Pencil in Violet

This is a purple-infused shade with a touch of black. If you have blue eyes, this is the shade for you. Try it with The Best Eyeshadow in Chic.

The Best Pencil in Ivy

Ivy is a slightly iridescent green with a touch of black. I love using this on people with green or brown eyes. It’s super versatile and pairs well with The Best Eyeshadow in Cream.

The Best Pencil in Onyx

Onyx is a great shade if you just want to dip your toe into the world of colorful liner. This shade is a soft black with silver pearl shimmer, kind of like The Best Pencil in Black meets The Best Pencil in Silver. It works on every eye color, making it super versatile. Try it with The Best Eyeshadow in Antique Rose or any cool-toned shade.